I joined my local MOMS Club when Max was just a baby and Maddie was about two and a half years old.
I joined the group even though I have a general disdain for large groups of women. I also tend to have a general distrust of mothers, especially mothers who stay at home because it's 'The Best Thing'. Because I don't actually believe there is such a thing.
But I joined the group anyway because, just like in every group, there are always some nice people. There may even be people who have a realistic view of motherhood. People who are maybe as frazzled and overwhelmed by the job as I am. Also, I'm lazy when it comes to making new friends. Setting up play dates makes me break into hives. With this group I am able to be a passive participant in social activities. I like that.
Of course that's not to say I have been a passive member of the group. I wrote the newsletter for many months. Created the calendar. Ran the babysitting co op. Hosted playgroups and planned field trips to bagel shops and farms. Threw holiday parties and sweated my ass off while doing it. I've been involved.
I've continued to participate in the MOMS Club, in spite of it's obvious failings, because I am socially lazy and this group allowed me a lazy social outlet. And honestly not all the mothers in the group are one dimensional. Some are funny and interesting and have a rich life outside of being a mother and I like those types of people.
But then there are other women in the group who...burn me up.
A few months ago I attended what may always be remembered in my personal log of experiences as "The Worst Playgroup Ever"
I haven't written about it until now because I was willing to give the situation and the woman involved a break. Perhaps I misunderstood her. Maybe she's just retarded and judgmental in this one area...not as a person overall. Also, as I've said many times, I only say things on this website I would be comfortable talking about in real life. Possibly with less swearing and taking of the lord's name in vain.
Obviously I don't talk about my father's suicide in general but if someone reads that about me, I'm no longer ashamed of that part of my history. My depression isn't something I talk about in general (it's, you know, kind of a drag?) but I'm not ashamed of it. I don't care if someone knows I'm depressed. It's an illness. Similarly, I am not ashamed for you to know I have a small head cold right now.
Recently I had 'words' with a member of "The Worst Playgroup Ever" and I said, in so many words: 'I don't like people who gossip. I want nothing to do with women who behave like you do.'
[I won't bore you with the details. This is a bored housewife with nothing better to do with her time but gossip and be generally annoying]
I have a friend who keeps plastic rats on her desk. When someone in the office does something stupid or annoying...she turns a rat over and that person is 'dead' to her. If I had a desk or plastic rats, this woman would be a dead rat on my desk.
Back to the "Worst Playgroup Ever."
It began with various stories of the most atrocious forms of mothering. Abusive mothers, stories from a social worker friend which were so stomach-turningly horrid, I began to wonder what could possibly be the point of sharing these kinds of stories?
Does this make us feel like better mothers because we wouldn't shake our babies and put them into a coma? Do we feel like better mothers because we're not living in poverty and addicted to drugs, neglecting our children while we try to get our next fix? YES you're a great mother! Do we need to discuss how horrible other mothers are to prove we're good mothers?
I don't know, as I sat and listened to this particular woman share horror story after horror story, my eyes began to glaze over and I felt my soul leave my body.
Soon the conversation moved on to breastfeeding.
Before I go further, you should know how much I TOTALLY LOVE BREASTFEEDING! I love it! I love boobs! And milk for babies from boobs is GREAT! I can't imagine anything better for a child! And if it works for you and your baby then WOOO HOOOO! I think that's great!
However, I also tend to see situations in shades of gray and I think breastfeeding isn't THE BEST THING, because as I said earlier...I don't believe there is such a thing, globally.
But this playgroup quickly went from HORRIBLE ABUSIVE MOTHERS (who make us feel more secure in our own mothering...I guess?) on to HORRIBLE MOTHERS WHO CHOOSE NOT TO BREASTFEED!
It started with polite disclaimers about 'I mean if you can't...well okay...but if you can, how could you not give this wonderful thing to your baby?'
Then it went onto, "My husband [a resident at the local hospital] says, it's the 'country club mothers' who are breastfeeding. Not the lower class."
Onto, "My husband tells the women he sees, 'This is a magic pill for your baby. Scientists can't create this and you can give it to your baby.' "
As this woman listed all the great things about breastfeeding, I stood up, grabbed a jump rope from the corner and hung myself. Right there in the middle of the living room.
Actually I said...in my dry and off handed way that's 'off putting' for stupid people who are making stupid sweeping statements to a group of women with several different experiences...."Well I didn't breastfeed and just look at my children...they're sickly! And STUPID!"
Awkward laughter followed.
At that point I grabbed a horse tranquilizer from my purse and jammed it into my thigh.
I thought perhaps the comment about how stupid and sickly my lower class formula fed children are would stop the boob lady from talking about how WONDERFUL the boobs are and how lower class people don't breastfeed their children. Not surprisingly, it didn't stop her. On and on she went.
But as she spoke, she grabbed her bottle of diet soda and filled her children's sippy cups with it. Her children are three years old and 13 months old.
I looked around the room, looking for someone else to notice the absurdity of this moment. Does anyone here see the absurdity of this?
Diet soda is better than formula feeding your baby? Is this the message here? How could you not breastfeed! How could you feed your child DIET SODA? Doesn't the caffeine and the aspartame and the nutrasweet and the acidic tooth eating carbonation kind of cancel out the Magic Pill of breastfeeding?
Even more so than the insane things you're putting in your child's breastfed body with a sippy cup of diet coke, my point is: We all make choices and sometimes those choices may not be 'As Good' as another. But there are several factors that go into our decisions and we're all doing the best we can.
My kids were formula fed and formula isn't 'As Good' as breast milk. But then diet soda isn't 'As Good' as a lot of other child friendly beverage choices...and I don't give my kids soda. So maybe, in the end, it all kind of balances out.
We're all really just doing the best we can.
Well we're all doing the best we can and then some of us are being extraordinarily judgmental (and also as gossipy as a school girl) and making our own set of choices that may not always be 'The Best'.