This is going to be a really long post.
Years ago when I stopped speaking to my in laws, I was pretty upset about how things happened. It ate at me about 3-5 times a week. Then 1-2 times a week and so on until it really only got me all riled up when I talked about it.
Now, I rarely think about my in laws and when things come up with them I can barely even get my heart rate to rise. And there is definitely no smoke pouring out of my ears anymore. How did that happen?
Well time, of course, is one thing. It heals. But also I told close friends the whole long drawn out and involved story and that also helped. But finally, what finally did it, was throwing it all up in writing on a password protected Vox site. I gave just a few people I knew the password and let them read the whole thing.
The whole thing was a little wrapped up in the story about my father, so I'm sure that was all a little healing too.
I wrote it all down and left it up there for a few months and then one day someone asked to read it all and I suddenly realized it was a story I didn't want to tell anymore. I didn't need anyone else to hear it. I'd put it out there and now I was done with it. It wasn't going to help to know anymore eyeballs looked at it and knew what had happened. So I pulled the whole thing down and I was finally over it.
I'm hoping the same thing happens with the Ex-Landlord when I'm done with this post and we've gone through the two-plus month process of collecting our money from him. Although I think the final step will be publishing the judgement (a public record) so anyone else dealing with this person will know.
I've been so incredulous over the condescending, arrogant and bullying way this man behaves, I've never known someone to be so awful. So reliably awful. As I went through and pulled out emails to print in preparation for our day in court, I was amazed.
I've mentioned most of those emails here.
The one where he told us to shovel snow from the house to keep the basement from flooding and ice dams from forming on the roof (COMMON SENSE FOLKS!).
The one where he told us to remove our Obama sign from our yard.
The one where accused us of breaking his microwave oven ON PURPOSE
The one where he blamed us for the sewage back up in the basement because we....he never said how we did it...I assume he thought we shit too much.
The one about the tile in the bathroom falling off the walls because it got wet (but ignoring the fact that he put up tile using adhesive, not tile mastic).
Logan met with a lawyer a few times to get ready for the case figuring out the best way to handle thing and he came up with a large binder full of emails, notes, and pictures. And on Wednesday night he said, "I'm really serious, I don't think you should come to the courthouse with me. I don't think you'll be able to control yourself."
I said, "But what if I promise not to say anything?"
He said, "You'll still sigh loudly and incredulously at everything he says."
I said, "I'll wear a ball gag and a leash!"
He said, "That won't stop your eye rolling."
And I had just about enough anxiety about even seeing the Ex Landlord (how I want to use his full name) that I finally said, "Fine, I won't go." Instead I went on a Tastefull Tour with my friends to Eastern Market and other Detroit establishments. Supino can really take your mind off your douchbag* ex landlord.
*Only my opinion! Not slander or libel or whatever everyone is freaking out about on Twitter!
I left Logan to go in and present our case and bite his tongue off at the arrogant assholery of our Ex Landlord.
And
He didn't even show up.
He's kept this going for five months and he didn't even show up to try and defend his theft of our money? (Law Note: Your security deposit is yours until your landlord lays claim to it. If you disagree with his claim then he has to defend his claim to your money. Our landlord did neither, which meant he should have been liable for double the security deposit. Apparently the judge in our case doesn't do this unless this is a chronic issue with a landlord.)
We spent hours of time preparing to go in front of a judge and explain how wrong the landlord was to claim we were responsible for $2500 worth of damage to his home. We also wanted a clarification of what we understood to be state law that a landlord MUST send you an itemized list and if he didn't he forfeited our money. (Legal Note: Michigan State Law: 554.609)
And now, we did it all for nothing since when you don't show up for your court date, you automatically lose the case.
So ....we won! We won our money back from the landlord! It was ours all along. The amusing thing to me is that he had a valid claim to a damaged cabinet door in the bathroom (GARY), that we were willing to pay $100 for and he also could have withheld around $300 for a water bill I assumed he'd take out of our security deposit, but didn't mention it in his contractor's estimate or in any communication within 30 days of our move so he forfeits any claim. In that way I suppose we saved ourselves $400 by going through all this.
So now we wait 21 days to see if he sends us a check, he won't. Then we do something else and something else and it takes about three weeks and they get the money from him by going into his bank account or seizing and selling things until he pays us. A sherrif or Barack Obama does this or something.
What I don't understand and what's really frustrating from the perspective of a tenant, is how he's getting away with this obvious fraud without paying any kind of penalty for his horrendous behavior.
What possible incentive does any landlord have for the honest evaluation of damages and return of a security deposit if he faces absolutely no consequences for his illegal and unethical practices?
Okay now here's the part where I tell the whole story from beginning to end so when some poor sap like me is googling "Landlord Is Ripping Me Off" or "Landlord Won't Return Security Deposit" Or "Why do Michigan laws not protect tenants?" Or "My landlord is an incredible douchebag* how do I prove that in court?"
*just my opinion!
It's going to be boring and factual but I want to write it all out because we spent all this time on it and I'm hoping it makes me feel better.