I got my mother's group monthly newsletter this afternoon.
Among the usual entries, the calendar of events, a welcome to new members, a craft or two, was a 'Poem'.
A lovely poem about 'Group Participation'. A poem intended to rally people into action! To inspire! To encourage!
(Any Project Managers out there, please feel free to use this in your own organizations, I think you'll find it to be a great motivational tool.)
Are you an active member,
The kind that would be missed?
Or are you just contented
That your name is on the list?
Do you attend the meetings
And mingle with the crowd?
Or do you come to listen
Then crab both long and loud?
Do you take an active part
To help the club along?
Or are you satisfied to be
The kind to just 'belong'?
Do you ever give suggestions
When the club looks kinda sick?
Or leave that up to just a few
Then talk about the "clique"?
And then the program's schedule
That means success, if done
Do you put your shoulder to the wheel,
And work with everyone?
So attend the meetings regularly,
And help with hand and heart
Don't be just a member
But take an active part.
Think this over, member,
Are we right or wrong
Are you an active member-
Or do you just belong?
After the poem there's this lovely 'Motivational' discussion:
Someone has said that membership of an organization is made up of four bones. There are the wishbones who spend all their time wishing someone else would do the work. There are the jawbones who do all the talking and very little of anything else. Next come the knucklebones who knock everything everybody else tries to do. Finally, there are the backbones who get the load and do the work. BE THE BACKBONE...PARTICIPATE!
I'm just loving the use of name calling and negative comments about the current state of our group as a 'tool' to create a more positive and interactive group.
I'm finding this approach very odd, counterintuitive if you will. Using negativity to inspire people to participate? Reprimand, name call and then...magically, people will just jump at the chance to participate in the group.
I find the descriptions of the 'bones' of an organization to be particularly amusing. The language and descriptions of these parts of an organization, imply that if you are not participating in the group, you are one of the unflattering negative parts of the group.
There is nothing like being called a 'Knucklebone' who "knocks everything everybody else tries to do" or a 'Jawbone' who does "all the talking and very little of anything else", to make me just JUMP RIGHT IN.
This poem also leaves out some other key elements of a group run by women, many of the 'types' were covered by Jen at Mommy Needs Coffee. She coined the phrase 'PTAnal Militant Mom.
Now we're not talking about the PTA here, but the people are kind of the same.
I've mentioned my issues with my 'participation' in the past. That kind of thing kind of soured me on the whole thing really, and though I tried to resist letting a bad apple spoil the rest of the group for me. The bad apple got to smelling pretty badly and I found I really needed to avoid the bad apple. Instead, I carefully chose the things I would participate in to avoid smelling the 'Apple'.
I suppose that decision, makes me a 'Jawbone'. Or does it make me a 'Knucklebone'? Or simply a 'Wishbone'?
I just can't wait to get more involved, now that I've been insulted I have a renewed vigor for helping the group succeed!
I think this book might be helpful for someone. I'm really wondering which kind of 'bone' she is, all those 'helpful' emails helping me do my job. The constant pointing out of my errors and ways my job should be done. Hmmm....let's see, I think that qualifies Ms. Z as a 'Knucklebone' doesn't it? Oh, I hope she's taken her poem to heart!
I really wanted to spend time writing up my own little poem, but I don't have the time to be as obnoxious as some people.
-------------Update!--------------
Okay, a friend was so kind to be creative for me and she wrote me a poem. It's really pretty good and it fits pretty well. Maybe I'll submit it for April's newsletter. I mean, really I don't see it as negative as much as just a helpful reminder.
You may read it here. Thanks, Katie.
I will say this: Buh Bye To You, Ms Z.
Hey, remind me to stay the hell away from the PTA, okay?