Royal Oak Community Farm Rips Off My Husband. Boo.
[Edit: I've learned Arzika Events in Troy was asked to copy Logan's original art. It's true the artwork was gifted to the Royal Oak Community Farm and therefore Logan has no legal ownership of it. But copying another designer's original artwork is unethical at best and undeniably shameful at worst, in my opinion. As a reminder to those in a creative field: always have contracts to protect your work from, truly ugly bastardization. If you can't even trust a community organization like Royal Oak Community Farm to behave with integrity, I'm not sure who you can trust.]
....
I'm feeling so self conscious here. Like I should have a "theme" or story...and there's a lot of just what I'm thinking at any given moment I enjoy sharing.
So I'm just going to go with that.
Last year Logan and I started volunteering for the Royal Oak Community Farm. I did some social media things for them and Logan created a couple of logos for them.
My time, I'm not so concerned about because I have no (seemingly) marketable skills, and look at these opportunities as "resume building". However, Logan is a professional. He has a lot of things on his plate. He was excited to work on this project and happy to do it for free because we knew people working on the project and it was fun for him to create the design.
This is the logo and flyer Logan created for last year's fundraising event, Lettuce Rock, for the Royal Oak Community Farm.
This year, after using (essentially) free labor for all of his events for the last year, the director of the Royal Oak Community Farm decided to pay a company [Edited To Add: the copying company is Arzika Events in Troy, MI) to run his event (don't worry...you can still volunteer to work!). This company included a "design" with its service.
Apparently this (paid) event company likes to take someone else's (unpaid) design and recreate a shitty version of it.
Let me clarify a few things. Logan was happy to help a community organization do good. We were excited about the mission of the Royal Oak Community Farm.
Logan would have given them his logo to use for free, because he believes in the mission of the Royal Oak Community Farm.
However, when you use volunteers to build your business and then pay someone else to (namely, Arzika Events), in essence, copy their work?
I'm not sure what message you're sending. But I'm willing to say, it's not one of "community".
Shame on you Royal Oak Community Farm.
We're still on board with the idea of the Royal Oak Community Farm, but suggest you run your business model a tiny bit different if you really want to be a community based organization.
*Logan had a career high yesterday, I'll write about that soon. Hint: "This Is The Motor City, This Is What We Do."
***
[Edited To Add (after threat of a defamation lawsuit...which good luck since this is a written blog...)
It is my opinion that Arzika Events LLC and Royal Oak Community Farm has behaved in an unethical way by blatantly copying my husband's original artwork. My husband had no contract with the Royal Oak Farm as originally stated, so they are legally allowed to use his work as they have. However, it is, again, in my opinion and that of many reasonable human beings, lacking professional integrity to copy someone else's work and accept payment for said work.
As my husband and I have both said, we wish the farm good luck in its mission, however, calling out poor behavior by companies and community groups is far from "Defamation" or "Libel".]
***
[Second Edit: I contacted the Royal Oak Community Farm's director, David Baldwin, who is upset I didn't contact him first to tell him what I would write about this situation. As I am not much into having my opinions edited, it is fair to say I did not contact him before deciding to share my feelings on this topic.
In our conversation two things came up I feel could use clearing, in fairness. I was told:
- The company Royal Oak Forward hired to run their Lettuce Rock event has an in house designer and the logo was included in the price of running the event. (I knew this, as I mentioned above, but it's worth bringing up again for clarification.)
- Additionally the director mentioned he did offer Logan a paid job for another program he was running.
The in house designer copying another designer's work reflects poorly on Arzika LLC, in my opinion, that it was included in the price changes nothing about the ramifications of copying another's work. As a designer, even in-house, this is a no brainer.
The work the director mentioned he offered Logan is a fair point to bring up, that he was offered more work based on his volunteer involvement (something companies seeking free work often dangle in front of unpaid helping hands). However it changes nothing about the lack of community spirit and the professional and ethical implications of taking someone's original artwork and copying it. (Also, Logan started the paid job for Royal Oak Forward, was told they were "going in a different direction" and to send a bill for the work he'd done up to that point. He still hasn't received payment, but maybe it's coming.....heh *Hey! The check arrived today 2/16!)
Social Media can propel your business and event quickly. But treat your people poorly and it can just as easily burn your business and event.
Again, I wish Royal Oak Community Farm the best but strongly suggest they reconsider their practices.]
























