First of all: Here's what happens when you think Cocktail Playgroups are a good idea.
Oh My God you Guys I would totally write this now but I'm totally SHIT FACED!!!!! And the kids are staring at me while I do it! Look at this example I'm setting for them! I had three beers in three hours and now? I'm SO WASTED!!
Woops! Sorry honey, mommy just fell down! Can you help mommy up!? Where's my drinks honey? What do you mean this is the toy fridge? Madison, be a dear and fix mommy another Momtini?
Zzzz....no...nooo...honey Mommy's just resting her eyes.
Yes the New York Times revealed today that sometimes 'Mommies' are also 'Grown Ups' and they may share an adult beverage or two. Sometimes RIGHT IN FRONT OF CHILDREN!!! But please don't worry, they only drink beer, wine or cocktails after they shoot up in front of the children because we need the children's help to keep the needle steady.
No no no. I think Stacy Lu handled the topic with balance. She shared the risks of drinking, drinking in general has the same risks actually and also shared the idea that perhaps mothers having a cocktail together is just another example of mothers just being people.
No my comments are in response to the first round of comments at Blogging Baby, where I have a history with the Righteous Indignation of middle America.
The last comment I read was actually a decently provocative one, where someone suggested that drinking wasn't the problem but teaching kids that alcohol is a way to relax might be. I take that to heart and so I'm having a masseuse come to my house every day before I crack open any alcohol.
No, but really I do take that comment to heart because I think that's something to be mindful of as a parent. (This was not sarcasm.) (No really.) (See everytime I say it's not sarcasm you think, 'See? She's being sarcastic!') (But I am not being sarcastic. I think there is the risk that you send your kids the message that drinking = relaxing no matter if you drink with other moms or with your husband each night. It's something I think about.)
This as opposed to Tina before that comment, who said, [I added caps so I can imagine Tina SCREAMING AT HER COMPUTER]
"HAVE YOU PEOPLE LOST YOUR MINDS? WAKE UP! KIDS DO WHAT THEY SEE. THEY LEARN BY EXAMPLE. KEEP DRINKING DURING PLAYDATES...THEN MAYBE YOU CAN ALL GET TOGETHER IN THE ER A FEW YEARS FROM NOW WHEN ONE OF THEM WRAPS THEIR CAR AROUND A TREE IN A DRUNKEN STUPOR....LIKE THEIR MOM TAUGHT THEM TO DO."
I'm always teaching my kids to wrap their cars around trees in a drunken stupor because everyone knows having a drink or two as an adult of legal drinking age in moderation means we're all totally shit-faced and then driving our cars around trees.
When our kids do that we'll have to look at each other and say, "Wow, we taught our kids to do that. We should be very very proud of us....Want to have a drink?"
But imagine this? I'm not sure I mind if my kids model my behavior. When they're adults, if they would like to enjoy a drink with friends, I hope they model my behavior and do just that. I hope they don't drink to the point of being drunk and I hope they're responsible drinkers when they're old enough to partake. That's what we're modelling really. We're modelling that with less wrapping of cars around trees and trips to the ER.
Right after I was interviewed for that piece, I asked my girlfriends if they wanted to be photographed for the piece at a cocktail playgroup. One of my friends brought up her concerns that the public would judge us (check out Flogging Baby for that) and that maybe the Times wouldn't portray us the way we'd like. At first I bristled with irritation ('Screw everyone!' I thought) but then, when I had to promise everyone, "It won't happen that way." I found I couldn't really promise that.
We all remember the Mommyblogging piece? The one Alice called "Vaguely damning". The thought of putting my friends in a picture where the Flogging Baby people could judge them left me uneasy and the thought of a picture of one of my friend's kids peering at an ominous wine glass in a national paper makes me want to throw up so I told Sandra we weren't interested. I almost changed my mind a couple of times but really? I just couldn't do that to them, I didn't want that over my head.
Not long after that interview, Logan and I went up to the Clarkston Union for Oktoberfest. While there we saw a crowd of mostly parents having a beer or two while their kids jumped in the moonwalk, or danced to the band or waited for face painting.
(Funny aside, the band that day was Strum Diggity who does not have a website. It's a kid's band led by a very nice lady who recognized Logan from this site and introduced herself after she was done singing. And then? It turns out she was the college roomate of Xiobahn. The world is very small unless you want to floss all the teeth in the world.)
And I wondered, what the hell is the difference here? Parents, responsibly imbibing. No one is stumbling or vomiting. We're just being people at a little festival...and we have kids.
Given that we're talking about drinking in moderation, like real right grown ups. Let's say we're talking about the generally accepted guideline of about one drink an hour. I'm just not sure it's something worth getting worked up about.
I love that site I just linked and how it points out all the hip slang for being drunk!
"Other words for being intoxicated include getting pissed, loaded,
smashed, hammered, buzzed, sloshed, wasted, wrecked, ripped and just
plain drunk"
I predict a night before the end of the year where I end up saying to Logan, "You know what!? I am Jush Plain Drunk." (Never fear! I will not be 'Pissed' in front of the children. Imagine what would happen then.)
I think what I'm realizing is how when discussing mothers sharing a few drinks, people's personal beliefs and experiences with alcohol come into play.
If you believe a drink = being shit faced. Then yes, you're going to have a huge problem with moms having drinks. If you grew up with a rageful alcoholic, you might tie alcohol to those behaviors and so all drinking might be 'bad' to you. Keeping those things in mind as I face the judgements of the internet kind of helps.
So much of what the internet thinks about you is how they perceive you through the filters of their own experiences.
Now that we've gotten the alcohol aspect out of the way, I also want to talk about another thing I said during that interview (which was ON THE PHONE! New readers: I don't like the phone. Or hugs.).
"It might just be a way of weeding out the mothers who are righteously
indignant about what other people do. I know I don’t need more
mothering guilt or mothering judgment in my life.”
You don't need to have a cocktail to do that, in my group of girlfriends it just cut through a lot of bull shit. If you think women who have a beer in front of their kids are irresponsible asses, you and I aren't going to be able to be friends. (FYI: If you're a baby eating Presbyterian, we're not going to be friends either.)
Not because I need you to love beer (or wine or cocktails) but because if a beer freaks you out then you're probably not going to like the fact that I am depressed and am on and off medication. You're also not going to like the fact that sometimes? I don't like my kids and I think they're being whiney brats and I want to put them to bed at 3pm or sell them on Ebay.
Last year we were standing outside the preschool and a woman was standing with my group of friends. We were talking about our weekend, the weekend where Logan as a shriner (in fairness to the anti-drinkers...that was a night it was actually good there were no children around. Whoa.) had gotten his fair share of Halloween. He left the first party we were at to go to a second party with one of my friends, I went home because I can't go that long. At parties.
My friend mentioned the ugly hangover she'd had the next day and the ride home they'd had to get from the party's (sober) hostess. We laughed about it, because in our world, everyone cuts loose sometimes.
The look of disgust on the other mother's face was so distinct I wondered if someone hadn't farted.
She didn't even attempt to hide her feelings saying, "You went to a party with her husband?"
Because going to a party together means you are having an affair. That's all it can mean.
And then, after she was done judging us for our open marriage, she said, "Wow, drinking? I guess you just kind of outgrow that kind of partying at some point. I mean, I just don't see the point."
It's true, I don't drink like I used to. We don't party like we used to. But we do drink and we do go to parties. And in that one brief conversation I knew this woman and I would never, ever be friends. Not because she chooses not to drink or go to parties anymore now that she's married with children.
We kind of couldn't be friends because it seemed, from her incredulous comments, that she didn't understand how people could incorporate versions of their former selves into their current life as mothers and wives.
Her life included tea and cookies at playgroups and quiet nights at home with her husband marvelling at the fruit of their loins and anything outside of that? Is Not. Normal. As I said, I've got enough guilt and angst in regards to my life as a wife and mother, I don't need help adding to it.
I don't want people like that in my life and if serving cocktails gets rid of those people faster? I'm happier because of it.
Let's have a cocktail.
Also? I got my hair cut and I just can't say enough nice things about it. I am in awe of what a razor can do to eliminate the mushroom. As my new hairdresser cut my hair, he said, wiping a drip of sweat from his brow (with the effort of it all), "Wow, has anyone ever told that for fine hair you sure have a lot of it."
I replied, "No...no one's ever told me that but...I think I love you."
Alex of Alex Emilio salon (new website: now) on Main street south of Fourth cuts the hair of many mothers I know. If you live in the Royal Oak area, I'm going to strongly urge you to call him.
Today while he cut my hair he asked what I do for a living. I said, "Well I write for a couple of websites. You've heard of blogs?"
And he replied, "Wow. That's great."
So he wasn't listening to me and still I don't care because this cut is amazing.